The coffee industry is no stranger to discussions surrounding the economic and social challenges faced by coffee farmers. Despite fluctuations in the Coffee “C” price over the years, many smallholder coffee growers still find themselves struggling to make ends meet. The prevailing inequity within the coffee supply chain remains largely unaddressed, leading to calls for reform. While it might seem simple to suggest that consumers pay more for their coffee to benefit farmers, the reality is far more complex. In this blog post, we delve into the underlying issues in the coffee supply chain and explore the necessity of a ground-up approach to tackle economic and social inequity.
The Value Chain Conundrum
One key aspect that often gets overlooked is the concept of value addition. The majority of coffee’s final sale value is added after it leaves the farm, with the bulk being added once the coffee reaches consuming countries. Martin Mayorga, founder of Mayorga Coffee, asserts that “trickle-down economics” only works when financial structures are equitable. Simply paying more for coffee doesn’t effectively redistribute wealth or address deep-rooted inequalities within the supply chain.
The Funnel Effect
Mayorga likens the coffee supply chain to a funnel, where the majority of the income generated stays with those closer to the market. This structural issue exacerbates the income disparity, making it difficult for farmers to receive their fair share of the final sale price. To address these issues, a ground-up approach is required, one that focuses on empowering coffee-growing communities with the tools they need for long-term growth and development.
Empowering Coffee-Growing Communities
A ground-up approach to supporting coffee farmers goes beyond mere price hikes. It involves sustainable, long-term development that includes technical assistance, education, and support for valuable infrastructure projects. This approach enables coffee producers to add and retain more value within their communities, reducing their dependence on paternalistic sustainability initiatives.
By supporting local communities, coffee growers can address long-term challenges in ways that align with their unique needs. This approach allows for greater social and environmental development while ensuring a higher percentage of the final sale price remains within the community.
Building Meaningful Relationships
Fostering genuine and meaningful relationships between coffee buyers and producers is central to a ground-up strategy. By eliminating intermediaries who often control the supply chain, coffee farmers can receive a more equitable share of the profits. Mayorga Coffee, for example, has been implementing this approach for 25 years, prioritizing the human side of coffee buying.
A Holistic Approach
Mayorga Coffee takes a holistic approach to its buying relationships, focusing on improving farmer well-being, long-term economic security, and agricultural support. They work with agronomists to support farmers in various initiatives, such as crop diversification to enhance economic resilience.
For example, after a coffee leaf rust outbreak in 2013, the company worked with farmers in Nicaragua to diversify their crops by introducing chia. This not only helped farmers economically but also provided a sustainable solution to the challenges they faced.
Balancing Profitability with Social Responsibility
An essential question arises when implementing initiatives like these: How do you fund them while remaining profitable? Mayorga Coffee operates on smaller margins than many competitors, ensuring that more value reaches both consumers and farmers. This approach addresses fundamental, structural issues in the supply chain, moving beyond the simplistic idea of pouring more money into the top and hoping it trickles down.
Conclusion
The coffee industry’s challenges cannot be resolved by merely paying higher prices for coffee. To address the economic and social inequity within the supply chain, a ground-up approach is essential. By empowering coffee-growing communities through education, support, and technical assistance, and fostering meaningful relationships between buyers and producers, the industry can work towards a more equitable and sustainable future.
Martin Mayorga’s perspective emphasizes that this approach requires a shift towards less greed and more equality. It may be a more daunting path to take, but it’s the only way forward if the coffee industry truly aims to address the deep-rooted issues faced by coffee farmers and their communities.
"*" señala los campos obligatorios
